Subscribe by Email

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Surgery on Tissue Paper Won’t Create Lycra

Francisco Canales, MD and Heather Furnas, MD in surgery with scrub tech, Carrie, all with sterile gowns, gloves and surgical masks and caps

Francisco Canales, MD and Heather Furnas, MD in surgery with scrub tech, Carrie

The quality of a plastic surgical result is impacted by two major factors:

  1. the surgeon’s skills
  2. the patient, specifically her anatomy, tissue tone, genetic scar potential, age’s effect on tissue atropy, health, and compliance with instructions.

The patient’s satisfaction with the surgical result is impacted by two major factors:

  1. the surgeon’s skills
  2. the patient’s expectations.

If a facelift patient with “tissue paper skin” expects surgery to give her “Lycra skin” she will be disappointed. The plastic surgeon can cut, move tissue, place key sutures, trim extra skin, and augment a receding chin with an implant, but no surgeon can turn tissue paper into Lycra.

How Anatomy Affects Results

In a facelift patient, strong check bones, a good jaw, and a well-defined chin provide the bony scaffolding for redraping of the skin, like a tent with proper-sized frame. Try draping a canvas top over frame that’s too small, and the canvas waffles, like a sail luffing on windless waters.

The elasticity of the skin also impacts results. Hold a never-inflated balloon between your fingers, and it feels rubbery and spongy. Now pinch it in two places, stretch it half an inch, and you feel resistance. The balloon pulls back against your fingers’ force. After you release it, the balloon bounces right back to its original form.

Next blow up the balloon just short of bursting, and then let out all the air and examine it. That once “youthful” latex is now wrinkled, thin and stretched out, and we can’t turn it back into its virgin self.

Skin is the same. Over time we lose elastin, and our supple, stretchable Lycra skin turns to dry, wrinkled tissue paper. And we can’t turn the clock back.

Plastic surgeons have skills, but we have no magic wand. patients who realize the quality of their own skin, bony structure, soft tissues, and healing potential contribute to the final result are likely to be satisfied if the surgery was done well.

Once a patient has healed and happy with the outcome, one major factor will impacts her long-term result:

  1. the patient.

The patient’s every physical quality will affect how long the results last, including:

  • anatomy (from bone to blood vessesl, from fat to skin)
  • tissue tone
  • genetics (impacting scars and aging)
  • tissue atrophy from aging resulting in volume loss
  • health
  • lifestyle and habits, like sun and wind exposure and substances ingested and inhaled.

Recently a 70-year-old patient complained that although at first she looked great after her facelift, after a year her skin had relaxed, leaving her feeling like she needed another facelift. I asked her to return so we could review her photos together to see how much she’d improved from before her surgery rather how much she’d lost in the last few months. But she declined.

Poor surgical results are evident early on, so if the results looked great the first few months, the problem was her tissues. They were 70 years old. Just like old, stretched-out knee socks that are put on at 8 AM and settle around one’s ankles by 9 AM, her skin had lost the elastic qualities that no surgeon could give her. Had she been 40, her skin would have held up like a brand new pair of knee socks…all the way until bedtime.

The following patient wanted facial rejuvenation. Let’s focus on her cheeks and jawline. Her skin is thin and wrinkled, particularly near the mouth, and her jowls fall below her jawline.

Lower face of Patient interested in facial rejuvenation

Patient interested in facial rejuvenation

A facelift improved her jowls and removed much of her loose skin and laser resurfacing improved the lines of her skin.

Lower face of Patient after facelift and laser resurfacing

Patient after facelift and laser resurfacing

But part of her aging changes included loss of volume, which a facelift doesn’t address.

Lower face of Patient after facelift, laser resurfacing, and fillers

Patient after facelift, laser resurfacing, and fillers

So after she had healed from surgery, she had fillers to add volume to her face.

What happens if a surgeon tries to create the look of Lycra out of tissue paper? If tissue paper skin is too loose after surgery, it follows that taking out more skin should give a tighter result.

Facelift scar 2 to 3 cm wide after too much skin removed

Facelift scar after too much skin removed

These two patients had facelifts done by a different surgeon who did just that. He tried to create Lycra skin by pulling and tugging, removing an extra amount of skin. Tissue paper skin won’t turn into Lycra, but it’ll scar. Like this.

Skin pulls apart just like a pants seam from your wardrobe twenty pounds ago. While the facelift incision might not actually result in an open wound, it will create a gap that scar tissue bridges. Because too much skin had been removed, the scars can’t be reduced.

Tissue paper skin can affect other procedures as well. A breast lift can improve flat, hanging breasts, but they won’t be full, round, and perky. That’s why patients with lifted breasts often want breast implants not to increase the size but give their breasts a rounded, more youthful shape.

Upper eyelids may still have a slight fold after an eyelid lift so the eyes have enough skin to close. Tummy skin that has lost tone, especially after massive weight loss may loosen up after a tummy tuck.

Plastic surgeons move tissues, place stitches that tighten, and utilize implants to alter shape and volume. But we can’t change the patient’s tissues, genetics, or anatomy. If a surgeon tries to create Lycra out of tissue paper, the patient is the one who has to live with the scars.

Remember, we aren’t magicians.

 

 

Dr. Heather Furnas

About Dr. Heather Furnas

Inspired by watching her plastic surgeon father operate in African bush hospitals, Dr. Heather Furnas followed in his footsteps, training at Stanford and serving on the Harvard clinical faculty. She and her husband, Dr. Paco Canales, practice together in Santa Rosa, California, where they raised their two children. (To learn more about their practice, visit www.enhanceyourimage.com.) She believes an informed patient is more likely to be a happy patient and is committed to providing that education. If you have any suggestions for topics you'd like to learn more about, she would love to hear from you!

Was this helpful? Let us know!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *